Skip to main content

Tyranny of the Masses

 


I was listening to Benjamin Netanyahu on the radio. He was justifying his change in the law that removed power from the Israeli Supreme Court, saying that it was the will of the people. Majority rules. This made me think of “Tyranny of the masses,” a concept that notes: just because a majority of people are for something, that doesn’t make it right. I am sure you can think of historical examples where the people of a country supported a policy that was demonstrably wrong. When everything is completely governed by majority rule, the rights of the minority can be subverted by the majority.

The framers of our American Constitution knew this, and tried to put in some checks and balances into our system of government. This was to guard against all forms of tyranny whether from a dictator, or from tyranny of the masses. One of those checks is that we have a representative government. The people themselves don’t pass laws, but instead elect representatives at the federal and local level to write the laws. A senator or legislator is not bound by the will of the people he or she represents, but can vote their conscience. Obviously, if they go against their constituents too many times, they will find themselves voted out of office in the next election, but the freedom is there for a representative to vote however they wish. Another check against tyranny is that we have three branches of government: executive, legislative, and judicial. If one branch goes too far, it can be thwarted by one of the other branches. That only works if the branches are separated and not all controlled by the same group of people. If the popular majority forces their representatives to create a law that oppresses a minority, it could be vetoed by the president or, failing that, be struck down by the courts.

Countries that don’t have strong constitutional protections, could find themselves susceptible to all forms of tyranny. Yet sometimes even a strong constitution cannot solve the problem. In the 1800’s there were states in America where the majority felt that slavery was an acceptable institution. In the states of the North the majority felt that slavery was an abomination. There did not seem to be any legislative or judicial way out of this impasse. The country elected an antislavery president. The South could claim they were the victims of tyranny of the masses of the majority North, because they did not want to lose their institution that they believed in. The North could claim that each of the southern states were a tyranny of the masses, clearly oppressing a minority. The South rebelled and we had the tragedy of the American Civil War.

There has to be better ways of solving differences than war. How do we avoid such an extreme? We could do worse that to heed Thomas Jefferson (a southerner’s) words:

We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness.

If we all believed that, and lived our lives by it, tyranny of the masses would never be a problem. Unfortunately, the Civil War happened even after those words were written. Ultimately, its about people. Government is people. As long as people hold Jefferson’s words to be true, democracy works. If they don’t, it doesn’t.

Star Liner

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Second Wind

  You have heard about athletes getting their second wind? It is not that they feel better, that they are warmed up and ready to run more easily. It is not psychological (at least, not all psychological). No. There is an actual physiological truth to a second wind. It all has to do with respiration. When I say respiration, I am not talking about breathing. Respiration is a biochemical process that happens at the cellular level. It is how the cell gets energy. There are lots of chemical processes that are constantly going on in each cell, and those processes require energy. Without a constant feed of energy, the cell will die. The more demands there are on a cell, the more energy it needs. For example, every one of your muscle cells need more energy when you are running.   In fact, you won’t be able to run if the cells don’t have sufficient energy for it. The energy currency of the cell is a molecule called ATP. You may have heard that sugar is how our bodies get energy, wh...
1 comment
Read more

The Outsider

  I am reading The Outsider by Stephen King. The first 150 pages or so I found disturbing. Not for the reason you might think. It is not scary, not creepy in a traditional horror way, but disturbing in a tragic way. The first hundred to 150 pages is tragedy on top of tragedy. The most disturbing thing to me (it is disturbing to me anytime I encounter it in any story) is a false accusation. A man is falsely accused and may well be convicted of a horrific crime. That kind of thing disturbs my soul. It makes the whole world seem wrong. I have always been disturbed by stories with that kind of thing. And why not? It happens in real life too. That makes it all the more horrific. In the Jim Crow South, all you had to do was make an accusation against a black man to set the lynch mob in action. No need to bother with a trial. But even if there was a trial, the outcome was a foregone conclusion, innocent or not. We see Vladimir Putin inventing charges against people and they get locked up...
1 comment
Read more

A Child of the . . .

  What was it like to grow up as a child in the 90s? How about the 1940’s? Thinking about a child growing up in each different decade, conjures up images in my mind. But that is all they are: images. I was a child in the 1960’s. I can tell you what it felt like to be growing up in the 60’s and 70’s, but what it felt like to me is not what the history books remember. History will tell you the 60’s was about the Viet Nam War, civil rights, and the space race. The 70’s was Disco and Watergate. I remember being aware of all of those things, but to me this era was about finding time to play with my friends, something I probably share with a child of any decade. It was about navigating the social intricacies of school.   It was about the Beatles, Three Dog Night, The Moody Blues, The Animals, Jefferson Airplane. It was Bullwinkle, the Wonderful World of Color, and Ed Sullivan. There are things that a kid pays attention to that the grown-ups don’t. Then there are things the adults ...
Post a Comment
Read more